The Menaced Assassin. 1926.

The Menaced Assassin. 1926.
Rene Magritte

Thursday, February 18, 2010

EIDOS DASEIN


          The poetess describes an experience that occurred in her mind.  Language is necessary to describe that experience, but language gets in the way of describing that experience.  The first words on the page are an injustice to the phenomenological event.  Processing and analyzing the occurrence, the poetess seeks to deliver to the reader an approximation of what occurred in the her mind.  To recreate the moment precisely and place the experience exactly in the mind of the reader is impossible.  To describe the moment scientifically excludes the range of human history and emotion.  The moment was more than an electrical connection between synapses. Furthermore, every time the poetess tries to enrich the description through editing, by holding the moment in different light and at different angles, she no longer looks at the original event.
            Such is the work of the poetess.  “Human existence is a dialogue with the world, and the more reverent activity is to listen rather than to speak (Eagleton 54).”  But listening doesn’t mean understanding.  I will generalize (I think correctly) and say that few people listen to their existence, at least on a regular basis.  Of course, trauma causes all humans to pause.  Out of the small group who reflect at times not dire, a handful engages in occasional conversation with themselves.  Still fewer create a conversation with the rest of us.  The challenge for the prophet/poetess is to render experience through enlightened language for us to comprehend human existence.  Reification may be artificial, but it is necessary.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

SCRUTINY



In ABC of Reading, Ezra Pound stated, “Literature is news that stays news.”  Value judgments decide what is literature or Literature.  And who is to say whose values are to be applied?  Isn’t literature about a love of reading?  Isn’t literature ultimately about what makes us happy as readers?  Where can each of us escape in “literature” to forget our everyday world?  Is your literature the same as my literature?
Can we remove value judgments and scientifically appraise a work in the way Aristotle would criticize the poets?  Is it ridiculous to state that literature occurs any time two or more words appear together and leave it at that?  By this definition, a traffic sign that reads “STOP” is not literature, but a traffic sign that states “SPEED LIMIT 50” is literature.  There is no value judgment here.  Simply a mathematical formula that says what literature is.
Certainly, none of us wish to stare at traffic signs all day as a form of reading entertainment.  But at what point, when words are gathered together, do the words become literature?  Ogden Nash’s Poem Fleas goes like this “Adam had ‘em.”  Muhammad Ali, when asked to recite a two word poem, said “Me, we.” 
In The Best Creative Nonfiction, Vol 2.  Edited by Lee Gutkind, the opening essay is entitled The “L” Word—And all the Rest of us “Outsiders.” Even though the collection deals with nonfiction essays, these words apply to all literature:  “While categorization may guide us in our selection of reading material, most readers are simply seeking enjoyment and enlightenment from books—no matter how they are categorized. . . Publishers and newspaper reporters care the most about categorization, I think—not so much readers (p x).”
Is there a brand of snobbery or elitism behind anyone designating one work as literature and another work not literature?  Without a critical view, without this elitism, can one define literature? Whose view is correct?  Who needs this definition and analysis, anyway?  Can’t we enjoy a pulp romance novel without worrying about whether we are wasting our time not reading literature?  If we step back from stating what is good and what is bad (an arbitrary value system which we embrace but we can’t quite explain and which differs from individual to individual) and include everything whether good or bad, is this our most inclusive definition of literature?  It might not work for a college curriculum, but it should work well for the reading habits of the general public.
From Literary Theory by Terry Eagleton--“Like religion, literature works primarily by emotion and experience, and so was admirably well-fitted to carry through the ideological task which religion left off.”  Although this is a small burden placed upon the back of writers, the description is closer to the truth of what literature tends to accomplish.  Words are meant to touch our heart and soul and occasionally to tell us something about ourselves.  That’s good enough for me.

Thursday, January 28, 2010

An Exploration Into Critical Literary Theory

     With this blog I intend to record my thoughts and questions that occur while taking a graduate class entitled Seminar in Critical Approaches to Literature.

    Rene Magritte's painting of The Menaced Assassin encourages entry, so to speak. The entire body of world literature lies breathless and transfixed upon the cutting table of the assassin, who in this case is the literary critic.  Harsh halogen lights of theory illuminate each crevice, mole, hair, nail and eye socket of the individual work.    The practitioners of theory step to the table with their scalpels of intellect and predisposition to slice away at the body until the folds of skin reveal the decaying liver satiated with inert transgressions, the quiet heart that once bubbled with emotions, and the spongy brain of plot and imagination.  But with the life taken out of it, the breath of spirit gone, the movement of blood stopped, the fingers no longer grasping at truths, is this body of literature revealed in this sacrilegious manner something new and blasphemous?  In Magritte's painting, when the assassin  finished, the female body remained with a male head.

     There are two types of critics in the world:  1) Those whose occupation it is to dissect, discover and deliver ideas about a piece of literature, whether the work is nonfiction, as in biography, history or essay, or fiction, as in novels, poetry, plays or short stories.  2)   Those who are the writer/critic.  That is, those creative types whose preoccupation it is to deliver to the first type of critic all those imaginative works that allow critic number one an occupation.

     Critic number two's first concern is writing the new biography, history, essay, novel, poem, play or short story.  But critic number two must skillfully step away and turn the scalpel upon their own work, otherwise the world will bludgeon it with their blunt weapons of criticism.  Occasionally, the great critical creative types like T.S. Elliot, Ezra Pound, Gertrude Stein, Flannery O'Connor and Bertolt Brecht journey away from their own works to discuss the poems, plays, novels and short stories of their colleagues.

     My creative preoccupation is writing plays.  However, I find that every new piece of criticism I read enriches my experience as a writer.  Marvin Carlson, Walter Benjamin, Bertolt Brecht, G. B. Shaw, Michael Taussig, Peter Brook and Antonin Artaud, to name a few, write passionately about drama.  I never agree with everything they express, but I always grow as a writer after reading their critical works.  Perhaps I will grow as a critic.

     In Plato's Ion, Socrates mocks the interpreter/critic Ion.  Although the discourse of Socrates may be a satirical trap for his friend Ion, they are true words.  "And you have to understand his (Homer's) thought, not only his words—an enviable lot indeed.  For a rhapsode would never be any good if he didn’t understand what the poet says.  He has to be an interpreter of the poet’s meaning for his audience, and it’s impossible for anyone who doesn’t understand what the poet says to do this well."

     I look forward to this semester of 'isms in critical literary theory.